Skip to main content
Article

Managing Challenges and Risks in Franchisor-Franchisee Relationships

This article examines the multidimensional dynamics of the relationship between a parent company and its franchisees or dealers. It details the criteria used by manufacturers and brand owners when opting to grant franchises rather than managing outlets themselves, the critical importance of franchise agreements, and the nature of financial obligations—such as franchise fees—and associated sanctions. The study addresses operational risks, including the oversight of outlet standards, quality expectations, and financial matters, while also discussing how weaknesses in mutual rights and governance structures can impact brand value. Enriched by concrete case studies—such as the Subway franchise crisis in the global market and penalties related to dealer inventory in the Turkish automotive sector—the article aims to provide insights into internal audit and risk management practices within dealer networks.

In this article:

1. Introduction: The Economic Dimension of the Franchisor/Parent Company and Franchisee/Dealer Ecosystem

From an external perspective, the franchise relationship between a parent company and its dealers might appear to be a simple arrangement for the supply of products or concepts. However, as the network expands, this partnership evolves into a complex governance system that entails a multitude of financial, operational, and reputational risks. For industry executives, the core issue is not so much “How many new dealers can we open?” but rather whether dealers adhere to established standards, whether reported sales accurately reflect reality, and how the strategic decisions made at the corporate level impact the sustainability of the dealers.

Critical questions that industry executives focus on:

  • Are dealers truly adhering to the standards set out in their contracts? Do they represent us as expected?
  • Are all sales being reported accurately?
  • Do royalty or concession calculations reflect the actual situation?
  • Could a specific action taken by a dealer toward a customer expose the entire brand to legal or reputational risk?
  • Do the pricing, promotional, and territorial decisions made by the head office undermine the economic sustainability of the dealers?

Managing Challenges and Risks in Franchisor-Franchisee Relationships

The significance of these questions is also evident when considering the scale of the global franchise economy. According to the International Franchise Association’s 2025 Economic Outlook, the number of franchise establishments in the U.S. was projected to reach approximately 851,000 by 2025, with direct employment exceeding 9 million and economic output reaching $936 billion. In the same organization’s 2025 survey, 37% of franchise executives identified the availability, quality, and cost of the workforce as their primary challenge, while 15% cited weak sales and 12% pointed to inflation as their top risk. The survey encompasses 171 senior executives representing 229 brands (International Franchise Association, 2025).

In the Turkish market, data from the National Franchise Association (UFRAD) indicates that the sector has reached a scale of tens of billions of dollars and provides employment for over a quarter of a million people—a testament to the critical importance of this model to the national economy (UFRAD, 2024). Within this vast ecosystem, the secret to success lies in transparency, fair contract management, and proactive internal audit practices.

According to data from Medya Franchise, the franchise sector in Türkiye continues to grow, contributing between $50 billion and $70 billion to the economy annually. Comprising an extensive business network of over 3,000 brands and 66,000 outlets, the sector creates job opportunities for approximately 300,000 people (Medya Franchise).

These data should not be interpreted as representing the current total size of the sector, but rather as an indicator of the scale this model has reached in Turkey. UFRAD’s activities for 2026 further demonstrate that the franchise system continues to play a vital role in the growth and international expansion of Turkish brands.

Within such a vast ecosystem, it must be remembered that the relationship between a franchisor and a franchisee is not merely about the supply of products; it is a complex partnership involving the transfer of brand reputation, intellectual property rights, quality standards, and financial trust. A misalignment of expectations, a lack of transparency, or weaknesses in oversight can quickly transform this profitable business model into a “hub of crisis.”

2. Decision-Making Mechanisms for Branching and Franchising

For a company aiming for growth, opening branches using its own capital versus expanding through a franchise model entails entirely different risk, cost, and profitability profiles. While a company that manages its own stores faces higher capital requirements, it retains uncompromising control over the customer experience. The primary appeal of a franchise system lies in capital efficiency and the on-the-ground expertise of local entrepreneurs. However, if not supported by the right strategic steps, this advantage can eventually turn into the trap of “growth without control.”

Table 1: Comparative Analysis of Company-Owned Branches vs. the Franchise Model

Decision CriteriaOpening a BranchGranting Franchises
Capital and Investment CostThe entire capital is provided by the parent company. Growth is slow.The franchisee (or dealer) bears the investment costs, allowing the parent company to expand rapidly without committing its own capital.
Operational Control and StandardsControl rests entirely with the headquarters. The implementation of standards is more rigorous.Maintaining control becomes more challenging; errors made by the franchisee directly damage the reputation of the parent brand.
Profit and Revenue SharingThe entire net profit generated by the branch belongs to the parent company.The revenue model is limited to franchise fees, initial entry fees, and the wholesale sale of products.
Local Market KnowledgeIt takes time for the headquarters to learn the dynamics of different cities and regions.Local entrepreneurs often possess a better understanding of regional consumer trends, the competitive landscape, local business environments, interactions with public institutions, and existing commercial networks.
Risk OwnershipThe majority of risks—related to investment, operations, personnel, inventory, finance, and day-to-day activities—are borne directly by the parent company.A significant portion of the risks related to investment and daily operations is borne by the franchisee. However, risks concerning brand reputation, contract management, regulatory compliance, customer experience, and the governance of the franchise network are shared between the parent company and the franchisee.
Basic Model TypesStores or branches owned directly by the parent company; sales, service, or operational points managed by the headquarters.Various models exist, including single-unit franchising, multi-unit franchising, area development, master franchising, distributorship, and other dealership structures with varying levels of authority.

Source: This table was prepared by Teolupus based on research and industry analyses comparing the branch model—operated by the parent company—with the dealership/franchise model. The comparison covers key aspects such as capital requirements, operational control, revenue structure, local market knowledge, risk ownership, and organizational structure. The table is not derived from a single source; rather, it was developed through a comparative assessment of various practical examples and generally accepted principles of franchise/dealership management.

Opening branches using its own capital is a different strategy for a company than expanding through a network of dealers or franchises. A company that manages its own branches faces higher capital requirements but retains greater control over operations and the customer experience. In a franchise model, a significant portion of the investment is borne by local investors; in exchange, the central organization’s direct control over day-to-day operations is reduced.

The primary advantages of a franchise system are capital efficiency and the motivation of local entrepreneurs. Its greatest disadvantage, however, is the risk of “growth without control.” As the number of franchise units increases, it becomes difficult for central management to maintain a close, personal understanding of each individual operation. At this stage, control must shift from individuals to systems—encompassing ERP and POS data, standardized reporting, and internal auditing—or, in short, to the governance and management components of a formal corporate structure.

3. Strategic and Operational Risks: Dealer Network Management

3.1. Competition Among Dealers of the Same Brand

One of the most sensitive issues in dealer network management is territorial oversight. If the central organization creates excessive density within a single region—aiming to secure more franchises or increase product sales—the new dealer may end up siphoning sales from existing dealers rather than generating incremental total sales. In business terminology, this phenomenon is known as “cannibalization”—where sales outlets of the same brand compete for the same customer base.

This challenge is no longer confined to physical storefronts. A brand’s own e-commerce website, marketplace storefronts, mobile app sales, or rapid-delivery channels can also conflict with a dealer’s exclusive territory.

Consequently, a dealer agreement must define not only the geographical territory but also the protocols for managing digital sales, customer data, corporate accounts, centralized promotional campaigns, and the allocation of delivery-related revenue.

3.2. Maintaining Operational Standards

In the eyes of the consumer, every establishment bearing the same brand name is identical. If a franchise location neglects hygiene standards, employs untrained staff, implements incorrect pricing, or uses raw materials—or engages in procurement or service practices—that are unauthorized by the parent company or fail to meet quality standards, this is not merely a local issue; it is a global brand crisis. For this reason, parent companies require performance audits that consolidate various metrics—such as customer complaints, occupational health and safety practices, product expiration dates, and mystery shopper reports—into a unified framework. To ensure operational standardization, it is essential for the parent company to regularly assess the following areas:

  • Product and service quality,
  • Customer complaints,
  • Store and corporate identity standards,
  • Use of approved suppliers,
  • Hygiene and occupational health and safety,
  • Inventory and expiration date management,
  • Employee training,
  • Mystery shopper results,
  • Recurring issues identified via search engines, artificial intelligence platforms, and social media.

The purpose of an audit is not simply to “find faults,” but to provide assurance that a consistent customer experience is being delivered across the entire network.

5. The Importance of the Franchise Agreement: Rights, Obligations, and Sanctions

The Franchise Agreement serves as the constitution for the commercial partnership established between the parties. Operational or financial crises often stem from agreements that are poorly drafted, ambiguous, or contain one-sided impositions. For effective management of a franchise network, the agreement must clearly define the following aspects:

  • Territorial Protection (Exclusivity): It must be explicitly stated whether the parent company may open additional branches within the territory allocated to the franchisee, and how e-commerce sales will impact the franchisee’s revenue.
  • Compliance with Standards: Standards regarding corporate identity, interior design, menu/service pricing, and staff training.
  • Sanctions: Gradual administrative and financial penalties to be applied in cases such as failure to adhere to signage guidelines, underreporting of revenue, or breaches of confidentiality. Conditions for contract termination must be based on objective criteria.

5.1. Why Is the Franchise Agreement at the Core of Risk Management?

In Turkey, there is no specific “Franchise Law” that governs franchise agreements in a standalone and detailed manner. Instead, franchise agreements are evaluated within the framework of general contract provisions, commercial law, trademark and intellectual property regulations, and competition law. Decisions by the Turkish Competition Authority also indicate that franchise agreements may fall under the scope of the “Block Exemption Communiqué on Vertical Agreements” (Communiqué No. 2002/2). For instance, the Competition Board ruled that the franchise agreement between Marks & Spencer and Marka Mağazacılık qualified for a block exemption under this framework (Competition Authority Decision).

A well-drafted dealership agreement should, at a minimum, clearly define the following: territory and exclusivity; e-commerce channels; franchise or other fees; the use of advertising funds; pricing and promotional policies; supply obligations; quality standards; the right to audit; data sharing; performance criteria; renewal and investment requirements; breaches of contract; cure periods; and conditions for termination.

A critical point to consider is the boundary between the “head office’s right to set standards” and the “dealer’s scope for independent commercial decision-making.” In particular, matters such as the setting of resale prices, the restriction of passive sales, and non-compete obligations must be evaluated separately under competition law.

5.2. How Is Digitalization Transforming Dealer Audits?

In traditional dealer audits, an auditor would visit a branch, examine documents, and verify specific transactions through sampling. Today, a much more robust model is possible within a dealer network connected to centralized systems.

Data from ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning) systems, POS (Point of Sale) systems, bank transactions, inventory, orders, CRM, and e-commerce platforms can be analyzed in an integrated manner. This allows for the following:

  • Comparing POS turnover with bank and cash register records,
  • Testing the consistency between products sold and the raw materials consumed,
  • Identifying unusually high rates of cancellations and returns,
  • Comparing discount rates across different dealers,
  • Monitoring inventory turnover rates and negative stock levels,
  • Detecting alternative sourcing practices carried out without the knowledge of the central office,
  • Analyzing whether promotional campaigns or incentive/bonus schemes are being exploited or misused.

Teolupus’s ERP approach emphasizes that ERP systems—built upon streamlined and traceable processes—serve as the foundation for generating reliable data and supporting management decision-making (Teolupus ERP).

However, connecting all dealers to the same system introduces a new risk: data security. Under Article 12 of the Personal Data Protection Law (KVKK), data controllers are obligated to implement the necessary technical and administrative measures to prevent the unlawful processing of or unauthorized access to personal data, and to ensure its secure storage. The Authority further explicitly states that data controllers are required to conduct—or have conducted—the necessary audits. Therefore, in cases where a dealer processes customer data within a CRM, loyalty program, or centralized sales system, it is essential to clearly define the roles of “data controller” and “data processor” within the contractual agreement (KVKK Data Security Obligations).

6. Internal Audit of Branch Standards and Financial Matters

The larger a dealer network, the higher the risk of losing control. An effective Internal Audit function is the only mechanism that can ensure a parent company achieves its corporate objectives. Auditing brand standards and commercial performance goes beyond merely identifying financial errors; it also encompasses operational flaws that could damage brand loyalty—such as poor hygiene, customer dissatisfaction, or the use of unauthorized suppliers.

How should an effective dealer audit be conducted?

A robust dealer audit should not be limited to financial records alone; a three-layered structure is more effective:

Financial and fiscal controls: Central ERP/POS turnover data should be reconciled with bank and cash records; furthermore, franchise fee bases, commission and discount calculations, returns, inventory counts, and any unusual transactions must be tested.

Operational and brand controls: These should cover corporate identity, product/service standards, store layout, customer experience, staff training, cleanliness, occupational health and safety (OHS), and the use of approved suppliers.

Contractual and regulatory controls: These include reviewing regional provisions, terms of brand usage, data security, competition law compliance, the execution of promotional campaigns, and the verification of all required permits.

Teolupus’s internal audit approach is based on the risk-based assessment of processes, the examination of internal controls, and the transformation of audit findings into actionable steps (Teolupus Internal Audit).

Indicators of potential dealer risk

Problems within a dealer network often manifest as warning signs before they fully emerge. If management focuses solely on revenue rankings, these signals may easily be overlooked.

For instance, a dealer might generate high sales volume; however, if customer complaints are rising, inventory discrepancies are growing, and return rates are—for example—double those of comparable dealers, that dealer should not be classified as “high-performing.”

Key early-warning indicators that can be monitored at the dealer level include sales growth, gross profit margin, alignment between franchise/contractual terms and actual revenue, inventory discrepancies, return and cancellation rates, customer complaints, collection delays, the rate of discounts applied outside of official campaigns, employee turnover, the number of audit findings, and the duration of unresolved action items. Naturally, it is critical that these indicators be expanded, refined, and accurately applied by experts.

By consolidating these indicators, a “Dealer Risk Score” can be generated for each dealer. This allows for a prioritized approach, focusing audit efforts on high-risk operations rather than subjecting all dealers to the same frequency of oversight.

Dealer Audit Implementation Framework (Checklist Example):

1. FINANCIAL AND FINANCIAL AUDIT

[ ] Matching of dealer bank/cash reconciliations with the central ERP/POS system

[ ] Analyzing unregistered product supply (Material input/output ratios)

[ ] Confirmation of premium/discount calculations and stock counts

[ ] …

2. OPERATIONAL AND STANDARD COMPATIBILITY

[ ] Corporate identity (logo, decor, staff uniforms) control

[ ] Cleaning, compliance with Occupational Health and Safety (OHS) rules

[ ] Approved supplier usage audit (Local supply of cheap goods without the knowledge of the parent company)

[ ] …

3. CONTRACT AND LEGAL RISKS

[ ] KVKK compliance (Unauthorized use of customer data)

[ ] Compliance with competition and territorial restrictions

[ ] …

7. Global and Local Case Studies

7.1. The Subway Franchise Revolt and Quality Crisis

Subway, a US-based chain with one of the largest global footprints, pursued aggressive growth through a franchise model—a strategy that eventually led to governance crises. By prioritizing profit maximization, the brand permitted the opening of outlets within walking distance of one another, resulting in “cannibalization,” where the chain’s own locations competed for the same customer base. As individual store sales declined, the parent company’s mandated discount initiatives—such as the “$5 promotion”—effectively wiped out the franchisees’ profit margins (YCombinator/WSJ Reporting, 2024). Furthermore, the requirement to source supplies exclusively from a single provider—at high costs yet low quality (notably involving products like tuna, the quality of which became a point of contention)—triggered class-action lawsuits and the closure of hundreds of locations. The parent company’s disregard for franchisee profitability, coupled with a singular focus on collecting franchise fees, laid the groundwork for the collapse of the entire network. Consequently, the number of US locations fell from 27,100 in 2015 to 19,502 by the end of 2024, amid severe crises and legal battles. This scenario demonstrates how a system in which the parent company focuses solely on its own franchise revenue is destined to collapse in the long term (Subway franchise issues, Subway store closures).

Even if a campaign launched by the parent company succeeds in increasing customer traffic, it can still damage the brand network in the long run if it undermines the unit economics of the individual franchisee. Decisions regarding the opening of new locations, the sharing of campaign-related burdens, and dealer profitability should be evaluated together.

7.2. 7-Eleven Australia – Regulatory non-compliance at the franchise level

The case of 7-Eleven in Australia provides a striking illustration of the consequences of weaknesses in centralized oversight.

A 2016 investigation by the Australian Fair Work Ombudsman revealed that some 7-Eleven franchisees had underpaid their employees and deliberately altered records to conceal these actions. The regulatory body concluded that while 7-Eleven’s approach to workplace regulatory compliance ostensibly included control mechanisms, it failed to effectively detect intentional non-compliance. (7-Eleven investigation report)

Subsequently, a compliance program established between 7-Eleven and the regulatory body introduced measures such as biometric shift logging, a payroll infrastructure that could not be altered by either the franchisor or the franchisee, CCTV monitoring, and the creation of an investigative unit. By December 2016, the company had paid out more than 55 million Australian dollars to underpaid employees. In 2020, the Fair Work Ombudsman announced that, as a result of this compliance partnership, the company had implemented significant improvements to its payroll and time-recording systems (7-Eleven Proactive Compliance Deed).

Even though a franchisee is a legally separate business entity, recurring instances of non-compliance cannot be dismissed by the franchisor as being “none of their concern.” Inadequacies in data, auditing, and early-warning systems elevate such issues to the level of the brand itself.

7.3. Dealership Inventory Crises in the Automotive Sector

The supply bottlenecks experienced in the new-car market in Turkey between 2023 and 2024 brought to light the risks inherent in the relationship between distributors (parent companies) and automotive dealerships, demonstrating the significant reputational and regulatory risks that dealer networks can pose to a parent company. During a period when vehicles were difficult to source, some authorized dealers claimed that no cars were available to consumers while, in reality, they were hoarding vehicles in parking lots or engaging in unfair commercial practices—such as demanding additional cash payments above the list price (often under the guise of “accessories”). The failure of major automotive brands to implement effective “mystery shopper” programs, ERP tracking, and data analytics mechanisms to monitor their own dealerships caused profound damage to the distributors’ market reputation.

According to the Ministry of Trade, administrative fines totaling 51.9 million TL were imposed for violations of the “6-month/6,000-kilometer” regulation. Furthermore, 14 authorized dealers found to be engaging in activities that hindered access to new vehicles were fined a total of 66.8 million TL, and nine of these had their authorization certificates for trading second-hand motor vehicles revoked. The Ministry reported that the total value of fines issued in the automotive sector throughout 2023—as part of efforts to combat unfair pricing and the hoarding of vehicles—reached approximately 118.8 million TL (Republic of Türkiye Ministry of Trade).

A distributor’s centralized price list and brand standards are not sufficient on their own. Metrics such as vehicle allocation, inventory holding periods, customer price quotes, accessory packages, dealership-specific sales deviations, and various other indicators must be monitored through data analytics and systematic reporting.

7.4. Competition Law in Distributorship and Franchise Agreements

In distributorship relationships, risks do not arise solely from a distributor’s failure to comply with the rules. The parent company or franchisor may also, through the terms of the agreement, unlawfully restrict the distributor’s commercial scope.

The İtameks–Özelcan/Babymall investigation, concluded by the Turkish Competition Authority in 2025, serves as an example of this. The Competition Board ruled that Özelcan had violated Article 4 of Law No. 4054 by setting resale prices for its franchise outlets, restricting their passive sales, and imposing non-compete obligations that exceeded the necessary scope within its franchise agreements; consequently, the Board imposed an administrative fine of approximately 26 million TL. Certain allegations concerning İtameks were resolved through commitment and settlement procedures (Turkish Competition Authority 2025 Annual Report).

Monitoring a distributor does not simply mean “exerting control” over them. The parent company must also independently assess whether its own contracts, pricing policies, and channel restrictions comply with the applicable legislation.

8. The Teolupus Perspective

Trust between a parent company and its dealers should not rely solely on good faith; rather, it must be anchored in a robust data infrastructure and independent internal auditing. At Teolupus, we design “Governance in Franchise and Dealer Networks” processes across a diverse range of sectors—from retail and precious metals to media and logistics.

We conduct end-to-end contract compliance audits to verify the authenticity of financial statements submitted by dealers and to detect instances of revenue inflation or concealment through data analytics and risk indicators. By establishing performance measurement metrics and independent internal audit frameworks, we help SMEs and large-scale distributors navigate the growing pains of expansion, thereby safeguarding the reputation of the brands they represent.

To learn more about our comprehensive operational internal audit approaches, please explore the services listed on our website (Enterprise Risk Management, Internal Audit Services, and Regulatory Compliance Consulting).

A strong dealer network is not necessarily one with a large number of dealers, but rather one that is effectively manageable.

Franchise and dealership models enable companies to achieve faster growth with less capital, gain access to local markets, and leverage the motivation of local entrepreneurs. However, as the scale expands, a company begins to serve its customers through businesses that operate outside its direct sphere of control.

Therefore, the fundamental question for sustainable dealer management is not “Do we trust our dealer?” but rather, “Do we have a system in place to identify financial, operational, legal, and reputational risks within our dealer network in a timely manner?”

When well-structured contracts, integrated ERP/POS data, risk-based dealer segmentation, objective performance indicators, and independent internal audits work in tandem, a dealer network ceases to be merely a sales channel; it evolves into a scalable and controllable model for corporate growth.

9. Frequently Asked Questions

How should a parent company manage dealer risks?

Dealer risk management does not end with the signing of a contract. A dealer’s financial status, sales and inventory data, customer complaints, adherence to standards, regulatory risks, and internal audit findings should be monitored periodically; high-risk dealers should be audited more frequently.

How is a franchise/dealership audit conducted?

The turnover reported by a dealer should be cross-checked against data from POS systems, ERP systems, bank records, cash registers, inventory records, and—where necessary—product/raw material consumption data. Particular attention should be paid to analyzing returns, cancellations, and promotional activities.

Is dealer performance measured solely by sales?

No. In addition to sales, other indicators—such as profitability, collection performance, inventory discrepancies, customer complaints, service standards, employee turnover rates, audit findings, and regulatory compliance—should be evaluated collectively.

What are the risks of opening too many dealerships in the same region?

If a new point of sale fails to increase total demand and instead merely splits the existing customer base, the outlets of the same brand end up cannibalizing each other’s revenue. Therefore, location decisions should not be based solely on initial franchise fees or potential royalty income.

Can the parent company be affected by a dealer’s regulatory violations?

While the nature of legal liability varies depending on the specific circumstances, a dealer’s conduct can directly impact the brand’s reputation and customer trust. In certain sectors, regulations may also impose specific obligations on the central organization regarding oversight or data security.

How frequently should dealer audits be conducted?

A risk-based approach is more effective than adhering to a single, standardized audit schedule. Critical or problematic dealers may require more frequent audits, while stable, low-risk dealers can be audited at longer intervals. Ideally, central data analytics should be performed continuously. The availability of internal audit resources is a key limiting factor in this regard.

What are the data protection (KVKK/GDPR) risks involved in dealer audits?

Dealers are required to securely store the personal data they process through CRM systems and loyalty programs. Under Article 12 of the Personal Data Protection Law (KVKK), failing to clearly define the roles of “data controller” and “data processor” in the contract—or neglecting to establish the necessary cybersecurity infrastructure—can expose the parent company to significant administrative fines.

What kind of solutions does Teolupus offer for dealership processes?

Teolupus; Through risk-based internal auditing, the integration of ERP data analytics, RPA and artificial intelligence solutions, enhanced traceability via dashboards built from diverse data sources, the establishment and maintenance of dealer performance metrics, and legal/contractual compliance audits, professional support is provided to help brands safeguard their revenue and commercial reputation.